Amish Lemon Sponge Pie Delight

This Amish Lemon Sponge Pie brings a bright and airy twist to classic pie desserts with its fluffy lemon custard and tender homemade crust. The pie features a light sponge filling created by folding beaten egg whites into a smooth lemon custard, making it feel delicate yet satisfying. Optional toppings like whipped cream, raspberry sauce, or raspberry cream cheese frosting elevate the visual appeal and flavor balance, perfect for any occasion that calls for a refreshing dessert.

I first discovered this pie at a friend’s family gathering and was immediately hooked by how the lemon sponge stayed tender and airy after baking. Now it’s a go-to when I want something special but not overly rich.

Ingredients

• All-purpose flour: for structure choose unbleached if possible for a clean flavor
• Granulated sugar: to provide subtle sweetness to the crust
• Salt: to balance flavors
• Cold unsalted butter and shortening: for a flaky tender crust cold fats are key for texture
• Ice water: to bind the dough without warming the fats
• Melted butter: brings richness and smoothness
• Granulated sugar (for filling): sweetens the filling evenly
• Eggs: separated, yolks add creaminess while whites lighten the custard
• Flour (for filling): helps thicken the filling without heaviness
• Whole milk: lends creaminess and balances tartness
• Fresh lemons: for juice and zest fresh zest adds vibrant lemon aroma
• Cold whipping cream (optional): for fluffiness
• Powdered sugar (optional): if you want a lightly sweetened topping
• Fresh raspberries (for sauce): give a bright color and natural tartness
• Granulated sugar (for sauce): balances the tartness
• Cornstarch: to thicken the sauce
• Water: to dissolve cornstarch evenly
• Cream cheese (for frosting): for tang and creaminess
• Butter (for frosting): for smooth texture
• Fresh raspberries (for frosting): for bright flavor and color
• Powdered sugar (for frosting): to sweeten and thicken frosting

Step-by-Step Instructions

Prepare the Pie Dough:

In a large bowl combine flour sugar and salt. Cut in cold butter and shortening using two knives or a pastry blender until the mixture resembles small peas. Add ice water one tablespoon at a time and mix gently with a fork until the dough is evenly moistened. Form into a ball flatten it slightly wrap in plastic wrap and refrigerate for 15 to 30 minutes until firm. Keeping the fats cold is essential to getting a flaky crust.

Roll Out Dough and Line the Pan:

Take the chilled dough and roll it out on a lightly floured surface to fit a 9-inch pie pan. Carefully transfer the dough to the pan pressing gently to fit without stretching. Trim excess dough and crimp as desired. The dough should be cold but pliable for easiest handling.

Make the Lemon Sponge Filling:

Juice and zest the lemons to measure ¼ cup juice and zest from one lemon. In a mixing bowl cream together the melted butter and sugar on medium speed until combined. Add the egg yolks one at a time mixing well after each addition. Stir in the flour and then the milk lemon juice and zest. Mix until the batter is smooth and homogeneous scraping down the sides as needed.

Beat Egg Whites and Fold Into Filling:

In a separate clean bowl beat the egg whites until stiff peaks form. Gently fold the egg whites into the lemon mixture using a rubber spatula taking care to avoid deflating the whites. Folding carefully preserves the light and airy texture crucial to the sponge.

Bake the Pie:

Pour the lemon filling into the unbaked pie crust. Bake at 325 degrees Fahrenheit for 55 to 60 minutes until the filling is set and slightly golden on top. Baking at a moderate temperature helps cook the filling gently without cracking.

Prepare Optional Toppings:

For whipped cream chill a medium bowl then beat cold whipping cream until stiff peaks form. Sweeten lightly with powdered sugar if desired and pipe rosettes onto the cooled pie just before serving. Make raspberry sauce by cooking raspberries and sugar until softened mashing and straining seeds. Thicken with cornstarch slurry and cool before serving alongside the pie. Raspberry frosting is made by beating cream cheese and butter till fluffy adding raspberries then gradually incorporating powdered sugar. Pipe frosting around pie edges for a colorful finish.

Pin it

My favorite ingredient is the fresh lemon zest it brightens the whole pie and reminds me of warm spring afternoons at my grandmother’s house where this pie was always served with a big smile.

Storage Tips

Store leftovers in the refrigerator covered tightly with plastic wrap to prevent the crust from drying out and to keep the filling fresh. This pie tastes best within three days. If you want to freeze it wrap it securely but expect slight changes in the egg white texture once thawed best eaten within a month.

Ingredient Substitutions

Butter can be substituted with an equal amount of margarine for those with dairy restrictions but the flavor will be less rich. Whole milk may be replaced with 2% milk or half and half for a creamier finish. For a gluten-free crust try a gluten-free all-purpose flour blend but expect a different texture.

Serving Suggestions

Serve slices chilled or at room temperature with a dollop of whipped cream or raspberry sauce. Pair with a cup of hot tea or a sparkling lemon soda for a refreshing treat. The pie also complements light salads or brunch spreads beautifully.

Pin it

Cultural Context

Amish cuisine is known for simple wholesome ingredients and hearty textures. This lemon sponge pie highlights their approach through fresh lemon flavor and a light sponge that contrasts traditional dense desserts. Its popularity reflects both the rural simplicity and a love for bright seasonal fruits in American midwestern cooking.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ How do I achieve a flaky crust for the pie?

Using cold butter and shortening cut into the flour creates small fat pockets that melt during baking, resulting in a flaky crust texture.

→ What is the purpose of folding in egg whites?

Folded egg whites lighten the lemon custard, adding air for a delicate, airy sponge that sets softly once baked.

→ Can I adjust the lemon flavor intensity?

Yes, by varying the amount of lemon juice and zest, you can balance tartness to your taste. Fresh lemons ensure vibrant citrus notes.

→ What toppings complement the lemon filling?

Sweetened whipped cream, raspberry sauce, or a fresh raspberry cream cheese frosting enhance the pie's flavors and add creamy or fruity accents.

→ Is chilling the pie before serving necessary?

Chilling helps the filling fully set, making slicing cleaner and enhancing the texture and flavors of the pie.